Close view of a gray painted timber facade, cream bay-window trim, oxblood glazed entrance door and a potted camellia on a worn stone landing.

Cole Valley's New Restaurants: Neighbors Shape Cole Street

When Peet's Coffee closed at 919 Cole St. in January after 12 years, the building owner first planned to lease the space to another coffee shop. Two groups that rarely act as one wrote to the owner together. One was the Cole Valley Merchants Association, made up of business owners. The other was the Cole Valley Improvement Association, made up of residents. Dan Serot, owner of Finnegans Wake and a founding member of the merchants group, gave the San Francisco Standard the letter's main point: "Please, we don't need any more coffee. We need food."

The space is going to Pasta Supply Co. That small decision shows how Cole Street changes now. The newest storefronts on the corridor's block and a half are mostly being picked, opened and in one case paid for by people who already live or work there.

A Corridor Too Small to Absorb a Duplicate

The commercial strip is a block and a half of Cole Street between Parnassus and Carl. It holds nearly a dozen places to eat, two coffee shops, a dry cleaner, a shipping store, a hardware store, an upscale grocer, a pet shop, a gym and an urgent care center. At that size, each storefront makes up a noticeable share of what the street offers. A third coffee bar at 919 Cole would have repeated something the block already had twice. Wooden Coffee House is at the center of the corridor, and Double Black, next door to the old Peet's, has drawn lines since it opened this summer.

The merchants association is young. It launched in 2023 and has worked as a practical lobby ever since. According to the Standard, it worked with the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency to move loading zones off the main street and shorten commercial loading hours, which frees up parking for customers. It also raised money for streetlights and the night markets. "We fixed the parking. I'm really proud," Serot told the paper. The letter about 919 Cole used the same coordination to shape which business would open.

700 Square Feet, Funded in Advance by Customers

Anthony Strong, the chef who owns Pasta Supply Co., lives in Cole Valley. He has also set up the build-out so his future customers help pay for it before the doors open.

The San Francisco Chronicle described the former Peet's as a "diminutive 700 square feet" with no gas line and no bar. It did have floor sinks, which made it, in the paper's words, "perfect" for Strong. He told the paper he has "no interest in a 90-seat restaurant space with a full bar that requires some massive buildout," and that "a space like this we can pull off on a shoestring budget." Strong is a former Pizzeria Delfina and Locanda chef. He opened the first Pasta Supply Co. on Clement Street in 2023 and a much larger Mission District location in 2024, which now serves as the company's production kitchen. The Chronicle reported that the Cole Valley shop will shape and cut its 30 fresh pastas at a station in the front window. Sauces and filled pastas will arrive daily from the Mission in a refrigerated van, and the cooking on Cole Street will be limited to prep, boiling and heating on induction burners. The existing floor sinks meant Strong did not have to spend tens of thousands of dollars trenching the floor.

He did not take out bank loans or use a crowdfunding platform. On August 12 he started selling prepaid pasta on the restaurant's own website to raise $400,000 for the build-out, Eater SF reported.

Offer Price What it covers
Pasta for a year $550 One box of pasta a week for a year, fresh and filled, not including the ready-to-bake lasagnas
Pasta for life $4,000 The same weekly box, with no end date
Corporate purchases 10 subscriptions Pasta Supply Co. donates one subscription to a San Francisco school

According to Eater, buyers can start picking up right away at the Mission or Richmond locations or wait for the Cole Valley shop to open. About a week after launch, Strong told the outlet the campaign was "well past halfway to our target." His reasoning, as he put it to Eater: "Why wouldn't we go straight to the people who are already buying our pasta?"

Rather than borrowing from a lender, the shop is raising its start-up money from customers who have paid in advance for pasta they can pick up weekly, with the option to skip a week. Any buyer who chooses the Cole Valley pickup will be a regular at 919 Cole before the first plate is served.

The Chronicle reported in August that the shop was aiming to open in October. Pasta Supply Co.'s own location page has listed 919 Cole St. as "coming soon," with hours to be announced. The Standard reported that the menu will include freshly made fusilli in spicy tomato vodka sauce and hot meatball parmesan sandwiches.

The Neighbors on Either Side Started the Same Way

Pasta Supply Co. will open between two businesses that took a similar path. Both are run by people who knew the block before they signed a lease.

To one side is Double Black at 925 Cole St., the café and store from the outdoor apparel brand Yardsale. Cristina Ashbaugh and Kelly McGee started Yardsale in their Cole Valley garage in 2023 and opened the shop this summer in a former pharmacy that had sat empty for years. Its iced hojicha lattes with black-sesame cold foam draw new visitors. The owners told the Standard they added free refills on drip coffee so regulars who might assume the place isn't for them still feel welcome.

To the other side is Simple SF, Abbe Hoenscheid's zero-waste refill store. Hoenscheid raised her children in Cole Valley. She opened on Carl Street in 2022 and moved onto Cole last year. She told the Standard that sales keep rising 40% to 50% year over year, partly because "we're the only zero-waste refill store in the city right now, so people have to come from all parts of the city."

Simple SF's growth shows how this works on Cole Street. The owner is local, but many of the customers come from across the city. The same holds for Double Black's lines and probably for Pasta Supply Co.'s pickups.

Where the Next Changes Are Planned

The other changes now underway follow the same pattern. Some details, including names and dates, have not been announced yet.

Address What was there What's planned or open Status as reported
919 Cole St. Peet's Coffee, 12 years, closed January Pasta Supply Co., from Cole Valley resident Anthony Strong October target reported in August. Location page says "coming soon"
925 Cole St. Long-vacant former pharmacy Double Black, from Yardsale founders who started in a Cole Valley garage Open since July
943 Cole St. Kamekyo, a 28-year-old sushi restaurant, closed in 2026 A new concept from Jiro Lin, chef-owner of Hamano Sushi in Noe Valley Expected "in the coming months," name not yet public
Parnassus, just off Cole A florist, which left in July Schatzgarten, an antique store from Katie Humphries Announced for September

Jiro Lin, who already runs Hamano Sushi in Noe Valley, is planning a new concept for Kamekyo's former space. Schatzgarten does not fit the local-owner pattern, since Humphries does not live in Cole Valley. She told the Standard that she went to her first merchants association meeting a couple of weeks before opening and that the group made her feel supported: "Everyone's so supportive, they're so organized." Her shop sits around the corner from Luke's Local, on the Parnassus side of the corridor.

Owners who already run businesses on the block expect a busier street. Jim Angelus has lived in the area since 2009 and has owned Cole Valley Tavern at Cole and Carl since 2018. He told the Standard his restaurant might "take a hit" when Lin's restaurant and Pasta Supply Co. open. He was not worried: "It's a long game. Ultimately, I think this is going to be great for all of us."

The Anchors Behind the Letter

The newcomers get the attention, but the businesses with the longest history on the street are the ones that steered the old Peet's toward food. Finnegans Wake marked its 50th anniversary in September. According to the pub's own history, it opened in Noe Valley in 1976 and moved to 937 Cole St. in 1989. It has been on Cole Street for 37 of its 50 years. The rest of the strip's long-running businesses:

  • Cole Hardware, open since 1920
  • Val de Cole, a liquor store and Legacy Business operating since the 1930s
  • Say Cheese, the deli and specialty food store, open for 50 years
  • Cole Valley Tavern, which went by Kezar Bar & Restaurant until 2022. One customer asked Angelus to keep the burger the same when the name changed.

The newer wave began around early 2024, when Woods Beer and Wine Co. opened in the old Reverie space a few months after Blue Barn moved in. Rising Star Laundry followed. Luke Spray, executive director of Civic Joy Fund, compared the change to West Portal, where local merchants "came in and said, 'Let's do this here. Why aren't we doing something in our own backyard?'"

"I do believe that Cole Valley is having a moment." Dan Serot, to the San Francisco Standard

December 10, Between Carl and Parnassus

The next time the whole corridor gathers is Cole Valley Nights, Holiday Edition. The street fair is presented by the Cole Valley Merchants Association with Sunset Mercantile and Civic Joy Fund. It is scheduled for Thursday, December 10, from 4 to 9 p.m., on Cole Street between Carl and Parnassus, with vendor applications due November 2, according to Sunset Mercantile's event page. The streetlights the association helped pay for will light the event, which runs in front of Simple SF, Double Black and the old Peet's at 919 Cole.

Leasing a storefront in a small district like Cole Valley takes more than a signed lease. The block's merchants and residents also weigh in on what fits. If you own a building on or near the corridor, or are thinking about a property here, Mollie Poe + Declan Hickey can talk you through how this works on Cole Street. Request a Confidential Consultation.

Work With Us

Renowned for listing some of San Francisco’s most sought-after properties, Mollie and Declan leverage their close collaboration, a hands-on integrated effort, where they work in tandem with an elite network of industry professionals, ensuring the flawless execution of every project from concept to completion. Deeply attuned to the pulse of the city’s ever-evolving real estate market, optimal results for their clients is a guarantee. Embark on your real estate journey with them today and discover the unparalleled advantage of working with seasoned experts who are passionately committed to turning your aspirations into reality.

Follow Me on Instagram